Frank Shaw (1940-1946)*

Charles Pfannes (1946-1951)*

Harold Hawkes (1951-1953)*

Bertram Tomlinson (1953-1955)*

Robert "McKinley" Stewart (1955)*

Gordon Stewart (1955-1957)*

Philip "Prussian" Kraus (1957-1959)*

Harold Ray Travis (1959-1961)*

Carl Aschenbrenner (1961)**

John Harbolic (1961-1967)*

Robert Wyant (1967-1968)*

George Harbolic (1968-1971)*

James Gilbert (1971-1973)*

John Henry Markham (1973-1975)*

Andrew Cody, Sr. (1975-1979, 1982-1983)*

Joseph Chapyak, Jr. (1979-1981)*

Joseph Linder (1981-1982)*

Peter Gilbert (1983-1985)

John "Jack" Delaney Sr., (1985-1987)

Alfred Roush Jr., (1987-1991)

Robert Outhouse (1991-1995)

John Novohradsky (1995-1997)

Andrew Roush (1997-1999, 2021-2023)

Timothy Donahue (1999-2001)

Reed Outhouse (2001-2003)

Michael Scott (2003-2005)

Jerry Andrews (2005-2007)

Alfred Roush III (2007-2009)

Thomas Grant (2009-2013)

Mario Cilento (2013-2015)

Stuart Bayer (2015-2019)

Jeffrey Faiella (2019-2021)

* Deceased

** Line of Duty Death